Financial Crime World

Title: Monaco’s Financial Sector under Scrutiny: MONEYVAL Report Reveals Money Laundering Vulnerabilities

Key Findings: A Hidden Haven for Money Laundering

  • Monaco’s financial sector is under international scrutiny following a damning report by the Council of Europe’s Committee of Experts on the Evaluation of Anti-Money Laundering Measures and the Financing of Terrorism (MONEYVAL) [1].
  • Monaco’s position as an internationally oriented financial hub makes it a prime target for illicit cross-border financial flows [2].
  • Most crimes are committed abroad, but their proceeds are laundered within the country [2].

Areas of Concern: Insufficient Risk Analyses and Supervision

Unsufficient Risk Analyses

  • Monaco faces significant risks from fraud and corruption, but risk analyses in these areas are inadequate [3].
  • Income tax evasion, a significant source of illicit funds, is not a criminalized act, and no thorough risk analysis has been conducted in this area [3].

Supervision of Financial Institutions and Non-Financial Businesses

  • Monaco faces notable shortcomings in its supervision of financial institutions and non-financial businesses [3].
  • Sectors such as real estate agents, property dealers, and private banking firms, which face minimal formal regulation, represent high-risk financial fraud profiles but lack adequate supervision mechanisms [3].

Prosecutions and Sanctions: Ineffective and Slow

  • The report raises serious concerns regarding the effectiveness of Monaco’s investigations, prosecutions, and sanctions processes [3].
  • Money laundering cases often go unidentified, and investigations take years to complete, limiting Monaco’s capacity to handle complex financial frauds [3].

Priorities for Monegasque Authorities

  • To address these shortcomings, the report advises Monaco to intensify its efforts in risk-based supervision and introduce guidelines for wealth management and private banking firms [4].
  • Substantial improvements in response times and a review of domestic legislation to limit appeal time frames are also vital [4].

Repercussions: The Risk of ‘Grey-listing’

  • Monaco is bracing for a one-year observation period following the report’s approval at the FATF plenary on 20 February [5].
  • Should the necessary reforms not materialize within this timeframe, the Principality risks being publicly ‘grey-listed’, as was the case in 2009 [5].

Monaco’s Response: A Determination to Meet International Standards

  • The Monaco government has assured EURACTIV of its commitment to implementing the report’s recommendations quickly to align with international standards [5].
  • The authorities have been working on legislative reforms since April 2022 to address priority concerns, particularly within the non-financial business sector [5].

[1] EURACTIV. Monaco: Money laundering, corruption, and tax evasion concerns persist. https://www.euractiv.com/news/monaco-money-laundering-corruption-and-tax-evasion-concerns-persist-news-1666160 [2] EURACTIV. MONEYVAL report casts shadow over Monaco’s financial sector. https://www.euractiv.com/news/monaco-moneyval-report-casts-shadow-over-monaco-financial-sector-news-1665132 [3] MONEYVAL. Mutual Evaluation Report: Monaco. https://www.moneyval.org/documents/MER/Monaco/AutEval-Monaco-2022.pdf [4] EURACTIV. Monaco to prioritise private banking sector, risk-based approach to anti-money laundering. https://www.euractiv.com/news/monaco-to-priority-private-banking-sector-risk-based-approach-to-anti-money-laundering-news-1666220 [5] EURACTIV. Monaco: Determined to meet international anti-money laundering standards. https://www.euractiv.com/news/monaco-determined-to-meet-international-anti-money-laundering-standards-news-1666434