U.S. Assistance to Afghanistan: A Delicate Balance Between Humanitarian Aid and Sanctions
=====================================================
A welcome step forward by the U.S. Treasury Department has cleared the way for the exportation of certain humanitarian-related commodities, such as food and medicine, to Afghanistan. However, aid organizations still face significant challenges in navigating the complex sanctions regime.
Uncertainty Abounds
The first challenge is uncertainty around who is sanctioned and what activities are permitted. The lack of clarity poses a major obstacle for international non-governmental organizations (INGOs) that often carry out last-mile delivery of humanitarian services. This ambiguity may result in more limited humanitarian engagement than intended, with potentially disastrous consequences.
Challenges Facing INGOs
- Lack of clear guidance on sanctioned individuals and activities
- Uncertainty around what is permitted and what is not
- Limited flexibility to adapt to changing circumstances
Broadening the Scope of Humanitarian Assistance
To address this issue, the U.S. Treasury should issue additional licenses allowing for a broader scope of humanitarian and development assistance in Afghanistan. This would enable crucial activities beyond basic humanitarian needs, similar to the approach taken with licenses for countries like Yemen.
Benefits of Broader Licenses
- Allow for more effective humanitarian response
- Enable delivery of essential services beyond food and medicine
- Help preserve livelihoods and social cohesion
Clarifying Sanctions and Convening a Meeting
A second challenge is the need for clarity on the scope of sanctions. The U.S. Treasury should convene a meeting with international stakeholders to discuss the implementation of sanctions and ensure that all parties are on the same page.
Importance of Clarity
- Reduces uncertainty and confusion
- Facilitates effective humanitarian response
- Enhances trust among international partners
Limited Release of Frozen Reserves
The United States and international community should allow limited, monitored release of Afghanistan’s frozen reserves to pay for essential imports, such as food, fuel, and health commodities. This would help meet the needs of ordinary Afghans facing food insecurity without giving the Taliban discretionary control.
Benefits of Reserve Release
- Helps address immediate humanitarian needs
- Preserves livelihoods and social stability
- Avoids creating unnecessary suffering
Preserving Delivery Mechanisms Through Civil Servants
The international community must explore ways to preserve delivery mechanisms that work through civil servants but are walled off from sanctioned individuals. This would allow for continued support to Afghan state institutions and prevent a hollowing out of the country’s fragile infrastructure.
Importance of Civil Servants
- Play critical role in maintaining essential services
- Are often most trusted by local communities
- Can help preserve social cohesion
Avoiding a Humanitarian Crisis
With these actions, the United States and its allies can improve Afghanistan’s chances of avoiding a massive humanitarian disaster with little risk (and possible benefit) to their geopolitical and national security interests. The international community must act swiftly to address these challenges and ensure that aid reaches those who need it most.
Conclusion
- Clarity and flexibility are key to effective humanitarian response
- International cooperation is essential for addressing complex challenges
- Swift action can help avoid a humanitarian crisis